The claim is often made that limitations inherent in pre-1925 acoustical recording technology adversely affected musicians and their performances in the recording studio. Certainly, the technology constrained the duration of recordings and, it is surmised, may sometimes have precipitated hastier performances as a consequence. Its relative insensitivity is also commonly thought to have obliged performers to adapt or exaggerate musical dynamics and perhaps give compensatory emphasis or weight to low-frequency sound in particular.

There are perhaps too many interrelated considerations to determine definitively the extent to which early recording technology altered musicians' musical intentions, but studies of comparable performances made either side of the 1925 watershed may nevertheless prove revealing - if not conclusively so.

In order to minimise the number of variables involved and to facilitate such a study of recorded piano music, I have compiled what I believe to be a comprehensive list of commercial piano recordings in which pianists recorded the same composition both acoustically, before 1925, and again electrically some time later. Forty-eight pianists in all, whose careers spanned the technological shift, re-recorded the same repertoire at least once in the electrical era. Some returned to it several times, while others had already recorded the same composition more than once during the acoustical era.

A number of reasons have been posited to explain why musicians were inclined to revisit repertoire  that they had already recorded. Indeed, there may be as many reasons as there were pianists: it is, after all, a practice that continued until comparatively recently. We might reasonably suppose that some, at least, whether for musical or technological reasons, were less than satisfied with their earlier recordings. Others may simply have relished the opportunity of re-recording compositions that they and their audiences loved. Certainly, record labels were keen for artists to re-record repertoire electrically that had already proved its popularity in the acoustical era. Others still, having struggled and chafed under the constraints of what, with the benefit of hindsight, we today consider primitive mechanical recording, may have been keen to make the most of the ostensible benefits of the new electrical technology. If this were indeed the case, we might reasonably hope that traces of the compromises that are so widely supposed to have dogged acoustical recording artists might be conspicuous by their absence in  later electrical recording of the same works.

I have collated a list of recordings to assist researchers and other devotees of early piano recordings in their study of musical performance on record. All the information - the data - is derived from Mike Spring's comprehensive discography of 78rpm (shellac) commercial recordings by classical pianists that is available on the APR website where further detailed discographic data can also be found.

The following list, comprising 774 entries in total, is arranged alphabetically by pianist. I have endeavoured to include all recordings of a particular musical work made by each pianist providing, that at least one version was recorded acoustically and one electrically. In some instances this involves acoustical recordings of excerpts that appear in later recordings as part of the larger-scale works.
I should point out that this is not a comprehensive discography of each pianist's recorded oeuvre.  It is simply a list recordings of musical works that each pianist recorded at least twice: once acoustically, and once electrically.

In addition to matrix numbers, a few audio files have recently been added; I hope to add more from time to time. For those entries where audio is available, links may be found in the right-hand column.